DANTE SOCIETY PRESENTS
ISSUING CITATIONS:
A space for graduate students and early career faculty alike to co-present, interact, and form connections across disciplinary lines.
Issuing Citations (IC) is a public-facing event series aimed at fostering research connections, nurturing inchoate projects, and providing an organizational catalyst for future conferences and publications.
For more information, or to learn about presentation opportunities, please contact us at admin@beatriceinstitute.org.
Past Presentations
KATHERINE BEAVIS
Katherine studied Classics and Art History at the University of Chicago where she focused on Fayum/mummy portraits in Greco-Roman Egypt. She is now a medical student at the University of Pittsburgh.
Having Fun with Shapes and Colors: Improving Visual Analysis Skills in Medical Students Through the Arts
All elements of medicine make use of the visual senses. On physical exam a patient may be jaundiced, awareness of line and form are necessary for surgical planning, and a radiologist may see a seashore on lung ultrasound. However, no form of medicine presents visual complexity like pathology. Line, shape, form, space, color, and texture must be closely observed and united with physiological understanding. This presents a challenge for medical students who often lack prior experience with visual disciplines. Presented here is a new approach to teaching histology and pathology that provides a firm foundation for future studies.
Raimundo Cox
Raimundo received his BA and MA in Philosophy at Universidad de los Andes in his home country of Chile. He now pursues a PhD in Philosophy at the University of Pittsburgh where his research focuses on Kant's metaphysics and its connection with his practical philosophy, as well as the methodological and historical aspects of Kant, Suárez, and Hegel’s thought.
Kant on Moral Conscience
In our everyday lives, we are familiar with the experience of moral conscience. It is the voice that tells us what we ought to do or avoid. Despite its important role in everyday life, the idea of moral conscience has become controversial in philosophy. It has been criticized for its religious connotations and also for its alleged role in reinforcing oppressive social structures and practices.
In this presentation, I will explore the nature of moral conscience by focusing on its role in Immanuel Kant’s moral philosophy. Kant’s moral philosophy is often criticized for being very abstract and rigorous and thus disconnected from our everyday moral lives. Yet, by exploring Kant’s conception of moral conscience, I will suggest that we can gain a much richer picture of his moral philosophy. Indeed, I will show how Kant offers us a compelling account of moral judgment and moral feelings. Moreover, I will defend that Kant’s theory of moral conscience offers us a promising way to reconsider its importance today.
Kant and the Question of Metaphysics
Since Aristotle, philosophers have aimed to develop a science that explains the fundamental principles and causes of reality. For centuries, this discipline—metaphysics—was seen as essential for grounding our understanding of the world, our moral principles, and even our religious beliefs. But in the Modern era, metaphysics came under increasing suspicion, and today metaphysical claims often strike us as obscure or untrustworthy.
In this talk, I explore how the philosopher Immanuel Kant confronted this crisis. Although Kant is often portrayed as an opponent of metaphysics, I will show that his project is not simply to criticize metaphysical speculation. Rather, Kant seeks to rescue and transform metaphysics by giving it a new scientific foundation. My aim is to explain, in accessible terms, how Kant redefines the scope and method of metaphysics and why his approach may still matter for contemporary questions about knowledge, morality, and religion.
AARON WEISEL
Aaron James Weisel is a doctoral candidate in systematic theology at Ave Maria University. His scholarship focuses on literary fiction as a mode of theological discourse. He serves Managing Editor for the Journal of Moral Theology. He graduated with his B.A. in theology and M.A. in philosophy at Mount St. Mary’s University, where he also played lacrosse.
Re-Enchantment & Literary Theology
Shaped by the skepticism and disenchantment of modernity, postmodern man has eschewed or forgotten his role in the cosmic drama, reveling in his subjectivity and engaging in the work of aesthetic self-creation. Even so, he remains haunted by the specter of the transcendent. Theologians may respond to this absence in the postmodern heart by turning to narrative: instead of crafting systematic propositions which demand intellectual assent, literary theology seeks to re-enchant the postmodern mind and heart by making theological claims in narrative form.
Sarah Moore
Sarah received her M.A. in Linguistics from the University of Georgia.
The Role of Language Background in Eyewitness Descriptions of Crime
This project investigates how language background influences the content of eyewitness-style accounts. English and Spanish differ in how they typically describe motion events: English often encodes how someone moves (e.g., running, limping) and the movement trajectory (e.g., into, out of, across), while Spanish more often emphasizes the people and locations involved. These patterns may matter in forensic contexts, where witnesses are asked to recall and describe crimes. Adult participants (18+) who are native speakers of English or Spanish will complete a 30-minute lab session in which they will watch 26 short, non-graphic public-space video clips depicting minor crimes (e.g., theft, trespassing, brief altercations) and provide anoral description of each clip as if giving a statement. Responses will be audio/video recorded, transcribed, and coded for motion components (Manner and Path) and scene components (Figure and Ground). Mixed-effects logistic regression will test whether language background predicts which details are foregrounded in recall. Findings will inform best practices for linguistically sensitive forensic interviewing and further research in bilingualism and applied communication.
"I Don't Expect to Be Forgiven": How YouTubers Navigate Identity Formation Through Enregistering the "YouTube Apology"
Apologies can take many forms, and "I'm sorry" can convey many meanings depending on the delivery of the message. In an attempt to better understand apologies made in digital spaces, this study focuses on investigating how YouTubers negotiate their online identity and resolve conflict while making apologies through semiotic strategies including language, dress, environment, and video recording techniques. It also seeks to find if the patterning of these strategies has become a mainstream, cross-linguistic template in an age of digitally mediated globalization.
Twenty videos from both English-speaking and Brazilian Portuguese-speaking YouTubers have been analyzed for the use of six apology strategies adapted from Blum-Kula et al's (1989) CCSARP Coding Manual for Apologies. Results of this study suggest that the "YouTube apology video" is enregistered via pragmatic apology strategies and semiotic devices across languages.
Alexander Exum
Alex is pursuing a PhD in Theology at Duquesne.
Newman, Aquinas, and the Creative Potential of the Conscience
To live and move as a moral agent requires the ability to discern good from bad and act accordingly. Were the good of the natural order made intelligible through the intentional ordering of those goods, then the moral agent would need a way to discover this intelligibility within themselves. This, for John Henry Newman, is the role of the conscience.
This discussion will trace two developments in Newman’s thought on the conscience: conscience as morally perfective, and conscience as epistemically significant. Understood within Aquinas’s distinction between objective impression (synderesis) and subjective disposition (conscientia), Newman shows conscience to be a real but deficient experience of God, who is intimately involved in the self-creation and self-knowledge of each human person. It is the voice of God which beckons from the center of human being as both limit and potentiality, moving the person toward what they were created to be.
Joanna Boyland
Joanna is pursuing a PhD in Logic, Computation, and Methodology at Carnegie Mellon University. Her research focuses on logic and programming languages.
A Translation for Proof-Theoretic Programming Languages
The field of proof theory discusses what makes a valid proof. It sits at the intersection of philosophy and mathematics. The field of type theory discusses how to categorize different constructs in a programming language. It sits at the intersection of computer science and, again, mathematics. It was gradually discovered in the last century that, in some rigorous sense, a proof of a statement is the same as a program of a type; proof theory and type theory are two lenses on the same concepts.
We will discuss a translation from one formal language to another, viewing both the source language and the target language through both these two lenses. I will share a nice proof-theoretic property of this translation, and briefly mention a nice computational property it has.
Juliana Knot
Juliana is pursuing her masters in Logic, Computation and Methodology. She studies in the Philosophy Department of the Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences at Carnegie Mellon University. Her research interests include causality, the history and philosophy of mathematics, and logic.
Correlation is Causation: Some Formal Properties of INUS Causation
Regularity theories, most famously articulated by David Hume, deny the adage: “causation is not correlation.” In “Cement of the Universe,” J.L. Mackie built on Hume’s description to ground causality as an “insufficient but non-redundant part of an unnecessary but sufficient condition.” I argue that coincidences contain more capacity for structure than previously shown and make plain how coincidences can yield to more thoroughgoing causal inference, analogous to graphical models. This account includes transitive causal chains, hypothetical reasoning, predicting outcomes of interventions, differentiating between chains and common causes, and discovering unobserved common causes.
Lucas Carroll
Lucas Carroll is a PhD candidate in Philosophy at Boston College. His research centers on the history and critique of metaphysics, on the phenomena of theoretical speech and the practice of dialogue, and on ethics and anthropology in the context of modern technology.
The Fragile Word: Metaphysics and the Conservation of Theoreticity
Lucas stages a connection between metaphysical discourse and the theoretical word. He argues that metaphysics is the reflexive self-affirmation of theoreticity as such—and that, this being the case, there exists a specific and urgent vocation of metaphysics vis-à-vis the human possibility for uttering a word of truth, for theoreticity. He sheds light on the concept of "theory" by resituating it within its originating metaphorical context. Then, he speaks about theoreticity-in-itself, and defines metaphysical discourse as theoreticity-for-itself. He deploys the primary theorem of metaphysics: "theoreticity is," and turns in his claims to the paradoxes involved in determining this affirmation. He resolves these paradoxes by exhibiting the real fragility of theoreticity. Lastly, he shows how, in light of the contingent subtraction of theoreticity, metaphysical discourse can be understood as the formal conservator of the theoretical word.
